contact us

Use the form on the right to contact us.

You can edit the text in this area, and change where the contact form on the right submits to, by entering edit mode using the modes on the bottom right.​

5218 Lawton Avenue
Oakland, CA 94114

510-654-9159

Oliver McCrum Wines has been importing small production Italian wine and distributing to fine retail and restaurant establishes throughout California since 1994. Over time, our portfolio of producers has steadily grown to over 45 producers from 15 different regions of Italy. We look for typical Italian wines with clarity and freshness, usually made from indigenous Italian grape varieties using clean, transparent winemaking techniques and no obvious use of oak. 

Blog

The Truth About Screw Caps

Michele Boscia

“Corks are so unreliable that we’ve developed a ceremony around it,” said VinPerfect founder Tim Keller in a recent article for SevenFifty about the proliferation of screw caps.

It’s true. There’s a reason the sommelier allows you to sample the wine and smell the cork each time you order a bottle at a restaurant. And, contrary to popular belief, it’s not to ask for your personal tasting notes. It’s because the odds that your wine has been ruined by cork taint (also known as TCA) or some other issue related to the closure such as oxidation are relatively high. As the diner, your role in this “ceremony” is to inspect the wine and point out any potential cork flaws before committing to the rest of the bottle.

While cork batch testing prior to bottling has come a long way over the years, about 1 in 33 bottles of wine are still ruined by TCA every year let alone other issues like oxidation. Can you imagine purchasing an expensive bottle of wine, aging it for a decade in your cellar, then opening to realize it was dead on arrival?

We can, because it’s happened to us more times than we care to admit. It’s for that reason that more and more producers are switching to screw caps instead of corks, and we at Oliver McCrum Wines & Spirits have been encouraging them to do so for years. While corks maintain the romance of what we’ve always associated with wine appreciation, they’re less reliable as a closure. That variability makes the purchase of an expensive bottle more precarious than it needs to be.

It took more than a decade, but it seems consumers have conceded that screw caps are suitable for rosé or a crisp summer white to keep in the fridge. That being said, we’re still facing a stigma against screw caps when it comes to aging wine and heartier reds. Case in point: the 2022 vintage of Ettore Germano Barolo, a wine that will most definitely benefit from years in the cellar. Despite the data proving otherwise, we’re still battling the misconception that screw caps won’t allow the wine to mature gracefully over time.

Luckily, we’re far enough along in the evolution of screw caps to have the scientific community’s participation, in addition to several decades worth of experience from producers around the globe. In the above-mentioned SevenFifty article, Michael Brajkovich, MW and winemaker at Kumeu River documents more than 25 years worth of vintages under screw cap, adding: “Recently we tried wines from 2001 under both screw cap and cork, and the screw cap was always superior. The cork-sealed wines tend to show high levels of oxidation as opposed to the correct bottle bouquet.”

We can attest to the same here at Oliver McCrum Wines & Spirits.

Amongst many others, we have ten years of experience with the crystalline white wines of Kuenhof under screw cap, every bottle perfect, with slow but clear development in the bottle, as a great example (not to mention some of the best German Riesling producers). With reds, we have fewer examples, but a comparative blind tasting of Sergio Germano’s 2017 Barolo Cerretta under different closures was very convincing: everyone at the table preferred the Saranex-lined screw cap (the Saranex liner allows slightly more oxygen transmission than the Saran tin-lined screwcap. Both screwcaps were evaluated in the blind tasting of Germano Barolo Cerretta along with whole bark cork, several versions of DIAM agglomerate cork and nomacorc).

Needless to say, we love screw caps.